Are We Too Obsessed with Mental Health? | A Christian Perspective

Woman sitting alone on a bench in prayer, Bible beside her—symbolizing faith over therapy culture

Reclaiming resilience, responsibility, and biblical wisdom in a therapy-obsessed world.

Somewhere along the line, mental health went from being something we manage to something we worship. What began as a much-needed cultural correction has turned into a full-blown identity movement. Everywhere you turn, someone is diagnosing themselves (or others) with a disorder based on a meme or a TikTok (*Guilty as charged). But what if this obsession with mental health is actually making us less well? Less resilient? More self-focused and less God-focused?

This isn’t a call to dismiss mental illness—it’s a call to reframe it. To stop medicating the soul with the world’s language when what we need is the Word of God. Let’s explore how we got here, what’s going wrong, and what it looks like to return to truth, clarity, and biblical healing.

1. When Sadness Became a Diagnosis

The Cultural Shift:
We’ve taken every hard human experience—grief, heartbreak, loneliness, discouragement—and slapped a clinical label on it. Sadness is no longer a part of the human condition; it’s now seen as a pathology to be treated.

What’s the harm?

  • We discourage people from sitting in discomfort and learning from it.

  • We pathologize normal human emotion, which makes healing seem unreachable without external help (pills, therapy, diagnosis).

  • It subtly tells people: “You’re broken. You need fixing. You can’t manage this without professionals.”

Biblical Reframe:

“There is a time to weep and a time to laugh; a time to mourn and a time to dance.” – Ecclesiastes 3:4

God designed us to feel. Jesus Himself wept at Lazarus’s tomb. Feeling sorrow doesn’t make you mentally ill—it makes you human.


🔹 2. The Danger of Label Addiction

What It Looks Like:

  • “I can’t do that, I have high-functioning anxiety.”

  • “I’m not rude—I’m just ADHD.”

  • “I have rejection-sensitive dysphoria.”

  • “My trauma response makes me act this way.”

Why It’s Dangerous:

  • Labels become identity instead of insight.

  • People hide behind diagnoses to avoid accountability or growth.

  • It creates emotional tribalism: “My disorder vs. yours.”

  • It flattens people into categories rather than treating them as individuals made in the image of God.

Biblical Reframe:

“Therefore, if anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation. The old has passed away; behold, the new has come.” – 2 Corinthians 5:17

In Christ, you are not your diagnosis. You’re not bound by it. You’re not defined by it. Labels can explain your struggle—but they don’t get to define your story.


🔹 3. When Therapy Becomes Your Religion

The Trend:

  • We quote therapists more than Scripture.

  • “My therapist says” has replaced “God’s Word says.”

  • Inner child work replaces repentance.

  • Boundaries replace forgiveness.

  • Venting replaces confession.

The Result?

  • Therapy becomes a substitute savior.

  • We become endlessly introspective instead of Christ-reflective.

  • Instead of transformation, we settle for management.

Biblical Reframe:

“Come to Me, all who are weary and burdened, and I will give you rest.” – Matthew 11:28

Therapy can be helpful—but it is not holy. A Christian therapist may point you to Christ, but Christ Himself is the Healer. Don’t confuse the lamp for the light.


🔹 4. Jesus Isn’t Your Therapist—He’s Your Healer

Cultural Misconception:
People say, “Jesus accepts you as you are.” True—but He doesn’t leave you as you are. His goal isn’t emotional validation—it’s eternal transformation.

Therapy says:

  • “Let’s talk about your feelings.”
    Jesus says:

  • “Let’s transform your heart.”

Therapy says:

  • “You’re doing your best.”
    Jesus says:

  • “Take up your cross and follow Me.”

Biblical Truth:

“He heals the brokenhearted and binds up their wounds.” – Psalm 147:3
“Go and sin no more.” – John 8:11

Jesus doesn’t just give us coping mechanisms—He gives us new life. He doesn’t help us better manage our dysfunction; He delivers us from it.


🔹 5. The Fruit of the Spirit vs. Feelings as Truth

Modern Lie:
“If I feel it, it must be true.”
“I feel anxious, so I am anxious.”
“I feel unloved, so I am unlovable.”
“I feel triggered, so you must be toxic.”

But Feelings ≠ Facts.
They’re real, but not always reliable. That’s why the Fruit of the Spirit exists—to override flesh-based responses with Spirit-filled ones.

Fruit of the Spirit (Galatians 5:22-23):

  • Love

  • Joy

  • Peace

  • Patience

  • Kindness

  • Goodness

  • Faithfulness

  • Gentleness

  • Self-control

Notice what’s not listed:

  • Emotional safety

  • Being validated

  • Getting your way

  • Being comfortable

Biblical Reframe:
Feelings can guide us, but they must be submitted to the truth of God’s Word.

“The heart is deceitful above all things…” – Jeremiah 17:9

The culture tells you to follow your heart. God tells you to follow His Spirit.

What Can We Do?

  • Reclaim soul care, not just self-care.

  • Encourage biblical resilience over emotional fragility.

  • Teach people to ask: “Is this sin, soul, or psyche?”

  • Normalize repentance, not just reflection.

  • Bring the Church back into the healing conversation.

And Finally:
God never promised a painless life—but He did promise peace. And no diagnosis, therapist, or trauma label can ever give you what only Jesus can.

Written by

You may know Elsa Kurt for her uncanny, viral Kamala Harris impressions & conservative comedy skits, but she’s also a lifelong Patriot & longtime Police Wife. She has channeled her fierce love and passion for God, family, country, and those who serve as the creator, Executive Producer & Host of the Elsa Kurt Show with Clay Novak. Her show discusses today’s topics & news from a middle class/blue collar family & conservative perspective. She also introduced a new podcast series called: Coming Out Christian.. Her book, Welcome to the Family (Life Behind the Thin Blue Line) has been called the “must have survival guide for new LEO spouses.” The vocal LEOW’s career began as a multi-genre author who has penned over 25 books, including twelve contemporary women’s novels. Her fiction stories explore the complex and relatable experiences of everyday life – the love & laughter, the heartbreak & sorrow, and everything in between. She finds the extraordinary in ordinary lives and puts you in the front seat of every story. Elsa has also written several children’s books, all with themes of encouragement, empowerment & uplifting messaging.

Leave a Reply

ELSA KURT’S

OFFICIAL STORE!

VISIT THE STORE HERE